Scientific policy advice: tasks, requirements and tensions
Grimm, GrimmPolicy Brief (32/2026)
Bonn: German Institute of Development and Sustainability (IDOS)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.23661/ipb32.2026
Dt. Ausg. u.d.T.:
Wissenschaftliche Politikberatung: Aufgaben, Anforderungen und Spannungsfelder
(Policy Brief 29/2026)
Science, politics and the public engage in dialogue on agenda-setting and problem-solving. This poses particular challenges for everyone involved, including scientific advisers. They are confronted with expectations and different role models and operate in different systems. In addition to this inherently tense relationship, there have been further challenges in recent years, with increasing hostility to science and disregard for evidence. Times of upheaval, in which uncertainties and complexities increase, on the one hand require scientific assessment and contextualisation, but on the other hand also necessitate reflection on the roles, demands and tensions involved in providing scientific advice.
The reciprocal relationship between science and politics is frequently viewed critically by the public and also by decision-makers themselves. It is, of course, also the subject of discussion in science itself. This policy brief considers policy advice in the context of political decision-making processes from the perspective of international political and social research as an applied science, based not least on the experience of the German Institute of Develop¬ment and Sustainability (IDOS), which closely integrates research, advice and training. Key statements are:
- Maintaining critical distance, despite the necessary degree of proximity, requires agreement on the role and purpose of policy advice.
- For science, the principles of critical questioning and non-partisanship apply. However, researchers are never “neutral”, but represent positions based, among other things, on internal scientific discussions on the weighting of findings.
- There are areas of tension between science and politics with regard to complex issues and scientific uncertainties, not least with regard to future-oriented questions, which are faced with expectations for simple, quickly implementable solutions. In addition, science and politics have very different time horizons.
- Advisory institutions specialise in particular areas of expertise. Their expertise must be grounded in sound scientific research (beyond institutional knowledge) in order to create confidence in their reliability.
- Ultimately, scientific knowledge must also be communicated to the society that supports it financially and as “knowledge as a common good”, as a form of public advice that con-tributes to society's ongoing process of reflection and self-understanding.
Further IDOS experts
-
Baumann, Max-Otto
Political Science
-
Baydag, Melis
Political Science
-
Bergmann, Julian
Political Science
-
Dang, Vy
Political Science
-
Erforth, Benedikt
Political Science
-
Furness, Mark
Political Science
-
Hackenesch, Christine
Political Science
-
Hailer-Röthel, Tim
Economy
-
Janus, Heiner
Political Science
-
Keijzer, Niels
Social Science
-
Klingebiel, Stephan
Political Science
-
Koch, Svea
Social Science
-
Löpelt, Sarah
International relations and Sustainability policy
-
Olekseyuk, Zoryana
Economy
-
Strupat, Christoph
Economist
-
von Haaren, Paula
Development Economics